Name: The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ
ISBN: 9781786891952

Philip Pullman

'If I vanished he wouldn't notice, if I died he wouldn't care. I think of him all the time, and he thinks of me not at all. I love him, and my love torments me. There are times when I feel like a ghost beside him; as if he alone is real, and I'm just a daydream.'This is the story of two brothers.One is impassioned and one reserved.One is destined to go down in history and the other to be forgotten. In Pullman's hands, this sacred tale is reborn as one of the most enchanting, thrilling and visionary stories of recent years.

The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ

Gavin

Or: "A Story." It's intentionally didactic, but that knowing intention doesn't stop it being annoying. Found myself reading it just to see what Pullman's next revision would be (e.g, Joseph being bullied into taking the teenage Mary for a wife). 

  "I remember him," said the blind man. "Jesus. He come here on the Sabbath, like a fool. The priests wouldn't let him heal anyone on Sabbath. He should've known that."

"But he did heal someone," said the lame man. "Old Hiram. You remember that. He told him to take up his bed and walk."

"Well what was the use of taking his living away? Begging was the only thing he knew how to do. You and your blether about goodness," he said, turning to Christ, "where's the goodness in throwing an old man out into the street without a trade, without a home, without a penny? Eh? That Jesus is asking too much of people."
  



Compassionate, subtler than the title suggests, dull.

Re-imagines the life of Jesus based on considerations of his dual nature, key Gospel stories, and the formulation of Church tenets.

Adam Valentino

A little disappointing considering how good Philip Pullman can be. I'm writing this as a diehard atheist and I still felt he was trying more to offend than entertain and the story suffered for it.

Xavier Roy

What if Jesus Christ was not one man, but twins, Jesus and Christ? This is their story.

André Nóbrega

I decided to read this book because I'm a fan of Philip Pullman since I read His Dark Materials, I'm interested in the exploration of the history and foundation of religions and I thought the title was curious and funny.

The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ revisits the story of the man that became a myth dividing him in two twin brothers, Jesus and "Christ". This allows him both to rethink the origin of christianity as a belief and religious organizations and create two men who are much more believable than the usual messiah as reported in the selected gospels and their official interpretations. The first step to achieve this is stripe them off their granted divinity, writing them into this story not as the sons of god but of a man that passed himself of as an angel doing god's will and convinced Mary she had to have sex with him.
Jesus becomes the biblical prophet, the one who gives the speeches, who announces and the coming of the kingdom of god, who provokes the religious and administrative institutions of his time. He starts of a true believer both in god and in the things he says about him, his wishes and his kingdom. But as time goes by and he never hears a thing from god, never gets an answer to his prayers, never sees any evidence of the kingdom, he starts questioning himself: "If that makes me a fool, I'm one with all the fools you made. (...) Is that what you're saying to me? That when I hear the wind, I hear your voice? When I look at the stars I see your writing, or in the bark of a tree, or the ripples on the sand at the edge of the water? (...) So, what's the answer? These things are full of your words, and we just have to persevere till we can read them? Or they're blank and meaningless? (...) No answer, naturally. Listen to that silence. Not a breath of wind; the little insects scratching away in the grasses; Peter snoring over there under the olives; a dog barking on some farm out behind me in the hills; an owl down in the valley; and infinite silence under it all. You're not in the sounds, are you. There might be some help in that. (...) If I thought you were in those sounds, I could love you with all my heart, even if those were all the sounds you made. But you're in the silence. You say nothing. God, is there any difference between saying that and saying you're not there at all? I can imagine some philosophical smartarse of a priest in years to come pulling the wool over his poor followers' eyes: "God's great absence is, of course, the very sign of his presence" or some such drivel.(...) When the fool prays to you and gets no answer, he decides that God's absence means he's not bloody well there." This is the man who believed in the god of the old testament, the one who creates, speaks, shows himself (if indirectly), who punishes and forgives, and in his name asked all men to leave all behind and work only to become almost saints. And that man could never be the one who stands for a god of men, absent, implicit, assumed, likely, a god who speaks only through the interpretations of people's words and self-proclaimed institutions. Further ahead in the same conversation from which I quoted above, Jesus says: "Lord, if I thought you were listening, I'd pray for this above all: that any church set up in your name should remain poor, and powerless, and modest. That it should wield no authority except that of love. That it should never cast anyone out. That it should own no property and make no laws. That it should not condemn, but only forgive.".

The purpose here isn't to prove anything new, the book is no investigation, no documentary, though it is based on the supposed factual reports and does keep most of the story of what we now believe might have been the life of Jesus. The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ presents itself as a story, but also and essentially as an exploration of the origin of stories and a provocation to the reader's mind, making him think or rethink Jesus, god or religion and its institutions. All this written by a man who clearly has a profound knowledge of the scriptures. It's an interesting book both to atheists and agnostics, christians and other believers.
There are two other comments I must add. Philip Pullman isn't insulting or disrespectful towards christians in the book. His tone is not that much one to make them feel foolish or stupid (as ends up happening a lot with militant atheists), but more to make them question the absolute belief in a church. There is a big difference between believing in Jesus' message, believing he was the son of god and believing in the churches that spawned around and presume to represent him. The negative criticism I have is that the author was too direct, too straightforward in his messages. It might have been better, both to read and to achieve any result, if those messages were a bit more implicit.

The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ is part of a collection of works on myth in which I'm now very interested.

This review was originally published in Portuguese on my blog.

adcv

Cody Degen

This is the story of two brothers. One is impassioned and one reserved. One is destined to go down in history and the other to be forgotten. In Philip Pullman's hands, this sacred tale is reborn as one of the most enchanting, thrilling and visionary stories of recent years.

Ed Kay

Michelle

Isobel 

Elda Mengisto

Kate Sigrist

Ri Liu

Jon Noronha

I think of him all the time, and he thinks of me not at all . . . This is the story of two brothers - one impassioned and one reserved. One is destined to go down in history and the other to be forgotten. In Philip Pullman's hands, this tale is reborn as one of the most enchanting, heart-breaking and thought-provoking stories of recent years, and questions what we believe and how we have come to believe it.This hardback edition is signed by the author

Daniel Waterhouse

Yulianna Aparicio

K. Qua

Luke Leighfield

Paulina 

Lisa Miller

Sam Spott

Akanksha Chattopadhyay

This is a story. In this ingenious and spell-binding retelling of the life of Jesus, Philip Pullman revisits the most influential story ever told. Charged with mystery, compassion and enormous power, The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ throws fresh light on who Jesus was and asks the reader questions that will continue to resonate long after the final page is turned. For, above all, this book is about how stories become stories.

Elke Maasbommel

In this ingenious and spellbinding retelling of the life of Jesus, Philip Pullman reimagines the most influential story ever told. Charged with mystery, compassion and great power, The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christ says something new about who Jesus was and asks questions that will resonate long after the book has been read. The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christis subversive, thought-provoking and deeply moving. Pullman's storytelling genius shows just why the charismatic person of a spontaneous, articulate Jesus has captured the hearts and minds of so many. Right to the end the betrayal of Jesus retains the intensity and suspense of high drama. As does the identity of Jesus Christ. The Good Man Jesus and the Scoundrel Christcould change the way you think about religion, about God, and about one of the most enduring stories of all time.